I got asked today what airline(s) I thought might be in real trouble.  Thinking about it for a few hours, I’ve come up with a sort of “death watch” list.

First on my list is Midwest.  They just announced they’re grounding their MD-80 aircraft and, as a result, cutting several important routes while expanding their codeshare with Northwest Airlines (who now owns a “passive” 47% stake in Midwest.)

Giving up routes such as Milwaukee – Los Angeles does not bode well.  With only Boeing 717 aircraft, they have limited themselves to routes that are “heartland” oriented.  For instance, the 717 can’t make it from MKE to LAX.  It can fly from Kansas City to Los Angeles (that route stays for now) but who wants to fly from MKE to LAX via MCI (MCI stands for Mid Continent International by the way)?  The airline business is, first and foremost, a network game and Midwest just cut 40% of its network putting itself below the critical mass in my opinion.

The proposed merger with Airtran would have saved them but they made a deal with the devil (Northwest) and Northwest has no interest in Midwest surviving really. 

Next up is Frontier.  Their hub is Denver and they have already cut back their focus cities.  While their fleet is new and fuel efficient, part of their business model counted on being the only LCC (Low Cost Carrier) game in town.  Not so true anymore. 

They have United Airlines above them as a legacy carrier operating a substantial hub in Denver and offering a nicely segmented set of seat choices and a global frequent flier program.  Below them is Southwest Airlines.  Southwest has entered that market with a vengeance and contrary to denials on te part of Southwest, it is crystal clear they intend to put Frontier out of business.  Much of Southwest’s growth has been focused on Denver and their CEO has already stated their intention to put more capacity into that city.  Denver can support two airlines, not one.  Since Frontier is already in bankruptcy, they’re my pick for going away. 

The only saviour is an airline that fits into their network and I can’t identify one that really meshes well with both their route network and their fleet. 

My third pick is Virgin America.  This is an airline that doesn’t quite know what it wants to be.  On the one hand, they want to be a trans-continental, high value, high service airline.  On the other hand, they want to be perceived as the west coast version of Jet Blue.   Trans-continental flights can’t make money using the equipment they have (Airbus A319/320) and their base, SFO (San Francisco) can’t support a real hub operation with good traffic given the competition they have from both legacy carriers and established LCC’s.

Filed under: Death Watch by ajax