I wrote a long blog post early yesterday morning about American and the rumoured order it was about to make.  Then, later in the day, the rumours started flying that it would announce the order today (Wednesday).  And, boy, did they.

Let’s look at the details first:

• 460 aircraft on firm order with both Boeing and Airbus
• Boeing sells AA an additional 100 current 737NG aircraft.
• Boeing sells AA 100 737RE aircraft with the CFM LEAP engine.
• AA takes another 40 options for the 737NG and another 60 options for teh 737RE.

 

• Airbus sells AA 260 A320 Family Aircraft
• 130 are for current generation A320 family with the sharklets to be introduced in 2012.
• 130 are for A320NEO aircraft (with arrival in 2017 and so much for talk that the A320NEO line was sold out.)

The aircraft will begin arriving from both lines in 2013 and American Airlines thinks it will have one of the youngest fleets in about 5 years.

So what does it mean?  Well, for one, the cost to announce this order was tiny compared to a traditional order.  These aircraft will be on operational leases and it appears AA didn’t have to put much money down for these firms orders (if any.) 

This order will be of dramatic benefit for the airline when it comes to saving on fuel.  If AA had a fully modern fleet now, it’s likely it would not have lost money this past quarter.   The benefit in fuel savings on this order will take a while to be realized. 

This is the first official mention of a 737 re-engine and I think we’re going to see some gnashing of teeth on the part of some airlines over the idea that a fresh design is likely 10+ years away.  This might be good for AA, it isn’t good, necessarily for Southwest Airlines or Ryanair.

This is a big win for CFM and its LEAP56 engine and while the engine is only announced for the 737RE, it is almost certain that that engine will be chosen for the A320 family.

What this isn’t is a loss for Boeing.  The post I composed and just deleted talked about how having a single source for your aircraft wasn’t really practical for an airline of AA’s size and all other SuperLegacy and Legacy airlines operate mixed fleets already as a function of a merger.  What those airlines have learned is that neither Boeing nor Airbus has a supply chain that can meet all their needs all of the time and on time.  It wasn’t irrational for AA to go to Airbus.

However, this is a pretty big loss for Boeing in the psychological warfare arena of aircraft sales.  This will be spun many ways but at the end of the day, Boeing got bruised and is not the aircraft manufacturer who gets to crow about success today.  Expect other SuperLegacy airlines to take a long, hard look at this deal and begin to negotiate for their own SuperDeals on aircraft with both manufacturers. 

Why did Airbus win more orders?  Because AA already has a large 737 fleet.  It didn’t need quite as many 737s.  This really is an order of equals practically speaking. 

I do think the A321NEO will be the 757-ish replacement and I do not think that AA will upsize aircraft to the 737-900ER down the line.  Therefore, I think the A320 family order will be either

A) A full mix of A319/320/321 aircraft with multiple bases or

B) A320/A321 aircraft with focused bases

I rather doubt that the A319 or the B737-700 will be ordered at all.  This order is about a marginal increase in capacity over time for most routes with the 757s leaving ever so slowly over time. 

And that points out a glaring gap that I haven’t seen anyone talk about yet.  Through this order and previous small orders, American Airlines will have upguaged their entire fleet and particularly so in the next 5 to 7 years.  Presently, the smallest aircraft in its fleet will be the 737-800 or A320 at roughly 160 seats.

What serves the 120 to 150 seat range?  The MD-80’s are departing and rightfully so.  American Eagle has CRJ-700s that are configured from 63 to 65 seats and AA is currently scope clause limited on how many of these aircraft it can fly.  Now, AA has also announced that it will spin off American Eagle soon and we’ll talk about that in a future post but that only means AA can (and will) access other regional airlines for its sub-100 seat flying.

What fills the gap?  If AA manages to get a new pilot agreement that allows AA to subcontract its sub 150 seat flying, I’ll be rather shocked.  I do not think the pilots are going to cede that territory under the current contract or whatever agreement is made for the near future. 

I realize that AA has been serving markets that might demand a 120 to 130 seat aircraft with higher frequency using smaller jets but it can’t do that forever.  Is there another order for aircraft lurking in the background here?  Maybe.  The Bombardier CSeries does fit that whole very nicely and does it in harmony with this announced order.  In fact, it presently is the only airliner that does.  Embraer gets close but it doesn’t quite get there.   If I were Bombardier, I would be knocking on American Airlines’ door with a most excellent finance package for its CSeries CS100 and CS300.

There is one more question lingering as well . . .

How will American Airlines paint its A320 family?  The aircraft cannot be polished like its 737 counterparts.  I strongly suspect we’ll see a metallic silver used with the current paint scheme over that.

Filed under: Airline Fleets, Airline News by ajax