In the latest financial results, most underperforming airlines attributed their lack of success to rising costs and specifically fuel costs.  Fuel costs did rise but let’s return to early fall when airlines were gleefully setting expectations for the winter season. 

Many airlines were so confident that they actually raised prices and talked confidently of record profits.  The problem is, the traffic didn’t materialize in many cases and I would attribute that to the fact that demand for the winter/holiday season is very dependent on price.  A few airlines did see that and held their prices or even had some sales.  Notably, Southwest Airlines kept a close eye on their demand and lowered prices were necessary. 

But the development that no one has talked about much but which is showing up is a rise in capacity.  That rise in capacity isn’t showing up in great numbers with new routes or increased frequency nearly as much.  Instead, it is coming from an increase in the size of aircraft on some routes.  Airlines are upsizing some routes and also increasing capacity through the aircraft they’re adding to the fleet to replace older aircraft.

Delta, for instance, has retired its smallest DC-9s in favor of Airbus A319 equipment.  American Airlines is replacing MD-80s with 737-800s.  Southwest is adding 737-800s to its fleet in about 1.5 years.  US Airways is adding A321s to replace 737-400s.  At first glance, these “replacements” are perceived to be a 1 to 1 exchange but in reality they’re often as much as a 10% increase in capacity per aircraft. 

The creeping rise in capacity shows that the industry isn’t necessarily in agreement on capacity restraint going forward and that could foretell a collapse in prices as these airlines chase customers to fill their aircraft.  I don’t think we’ll see huge losses in the next year but I do think we’ll see an erosion of profitability.   The airlines who possess fleet flexibility should fare better than those who are largely locked into large blocks of fleet types.  Think Delta vs American Airlines. 

Mergers didn’t solve an excess of capacity.  Not really.  They did bring some costs down but neither of the two big mergers had much overlap and capacity was therefore not really reduced much in that sense.  Since there are no merger candidates with much overlap in existence right now, I don’t think this problem is going to go away very soon.  The real solution is to actually let an airline go out of business.  The only candidate for that is American Airlines and they have lots of maneuvering room left presently. 

Look for capacity to be a bigger talking point among financial analysts over the next 3 months and particularly at the end of the next financial quarter.

Filed under: Airline News by ajax